M.I.A. Rihanna Diss

Melinda | February 28, 2010 | 92 Comments

M.I.A.Boyz music video Vs Rihanna Rude Boy music video

M.I.A. Rihanna Diss – M.I.A.”Boyz” music video Vs Rihanna ”Rude Boy” music video,pick your side.When Rihanna dropped the music video for her latest single ‘Rude Boy’ everyone said that it was cool but it looked like something they saw before.In less than 24 hours after the clip was in circulation ,it became more or less official that Rihanna stole the concept from the clip ”Boyz” off M.I.A.’s last album ”Kala.” But rapidly Melina Matsoukas, the director of RiRi’s clip denied the story telling MTV:

“I mean, you know that the video lends from a lot of Rasta culture and ’80s Atari vibe and that’s what we went with, too.And then afterward I was like, ‘Oh, this sucks. They tore down my video.’ And her video’s great too. It definitely wasn’t trying to rip anybody off at all — it was just our approach and the animation stuff, it had a similar vibe. We’ve seen that before with Grace Jones and Andy Warhol, so I don’t know if anybody can lay claim to anything. We’re all inspired by similar elements and it came together in that way.”

The man behind”Boyz” ,Diplo weighed in the controversy in an interview with MTV also where he said:

“I downloaded Rihanna’s album as soon as it came out because I was interested in seeing the pop world’s take on dub-step [musical style], because that’s what they were supposed to do.It was pretty weak except for ‘Rude Boy,’ which is one of my favorite songs of the year thus far. I’m glad it came out as a single, but when I saw the video I was like, ‘This is a total rip-off of M.I.A.’s “Boyz” video, with a little bit of Santigold as well.’ But it’s cool because she looks beautiful in the video. I just thought it was funny.”

But things really got heated last night when M.I.A. used her Twitter page to slightly attack the “Umbrella” singer.M.I.A. re-tweeted:

RT @KLAneedsREEBOX: if @Rihanna really sold her sole 2 tha deville than y cant saiten cum up wit sumpthin that dont look like a @_M_I_A_ …


What say you,Rihanna stole M.I.A.’s idea or you find the clips look nothing alike?



Source

Please share this post!

    Tags:

    Category: Celebrity Gossip

    Leave a Reply

    Comments (92)

    Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

    1. Wooowzer says:

      HAHAHA M.I.A. video looks mega boring and kinda cheap if u ask me.. Rihanna Rude boy looks way better… maybe M.I.A. just mad that Rihanna video looks

    2. Wooowzer says:

      BETTER!!! lol forgot to put that word lol

    3. Fancy2121 says:

      the mia video is hot there both hot its just mia went to jamaica to shot her video if u look it up that how we dance in danehall and if u eva go to a danehall party u would kno!!! so it has nothin to do with cheap its just a dancing ting!!!

    4. geekays says:

      I think sometimes pple overlook RIHANNA this is all becoz of jealousy…..RIHANNA’s video is far much superior than MIA’s ..these pple are angry coz RIHANNA’s is receiving so much attention..damn haters…da video for RIHANNA IS SUPER hottt so all haters go and s$$k yourselves…..to me RIHANNA is a PRINCESS….

    5. mooface says:

      firstly, mia retweeted a hilarious tweet. hardly dissing. Secondly, mia is the only person behind boyz. Which idiot is tryna claim her work next.

    6. Ace says:

      I don’t know I really think that they may have been similarly inspired but the mood and the affect is completely different. Rihanna’s using the elements of that style to convey a completely different message than MIA. They’re both valid and successful videos.

    7. d says:

      Just another proof that Rihanna is a gimmick and also that her followers are all morons.

      • CH3RRii3 says:

        shut up and sit down u retarded hater!!

        • BLAH says:

          Oh, yes, that was an intelligent rebuttal.

        • cheng says:

          you just proved his point by making a personal insult without any substantive rebuttal points. in fact you haven’t addressed his argument at all.

          in short: graduate elementary school first before you post on the internet again.

          • Rihanna what? says:

            HAHA HALF OF YALL PROBLEY NOT FANS OF MIA.YALL JUST ON HERE TO DISS RIHANNA…BECAUSE YOU DONT LIKE HER LOL

      • linx20 says:

        your damn right all of big forhead riri ppls follow her damn batty like come on the b$$$h aint that hot. my toe nail got more umph than riri

      • Onnie says:

        Your pathetic dude rihanna totally awsome and the videos are totally nothing alike they both sending out different messages to people and rihanna video is way better then M.I.A. video M.I.A video was totally boring and cheap what lots of color

        • hahahahahaha says:

          1. rihanna has way more money.
          2. rihanna is awful and her style is gross.
          3.rihanna is gross
          4.none of rihannas videos have ever looked like that, it was wikid trippy, and thats what M.I.A always goes for.
          5. rihannas music is terrible.
          6. all of you who are like, (OMG rihanna is awsome shes the best ever) are all moronic.

      • chashmer says:

        rihanna gimmick! in ur dreams.if rihanna is such a gimmick why do people now days trying to look like her and be like her…its jealousy.thats all it is

      • Rihanna what? says:

        LOL I FIND IT FUNNY THAT ALL THE RIHANNA HATERS ARE ALWAYS UPDATING RIHANNA TRYING TO FIND HER LITTLE MISTAKES. IF HER FOLLOWERS ARE MORONS..WELL HER HATERS ARE TOO! LOL

    8. Ria says:

      lol…
      Maybe they got some same elements but Rihannas Vid is definetly waaaay better…

    9. Kerry says:

      LOL… THIS IS CRAZY THEY BOTH HAVE RASTA COLOURS THAT’S ABOUT IS MIA GONNA SUE HER FOR SOMETHING THAT IS TOTALLY JAMAICAN… MIA GET OVER YOURSELF

      IN JAMAICAN MIA YUH BOMBOCLAAT

    10. CH3RRii3 says:

      rihanna video is hotter, and i love the song!!!!
      bye m.i.a!!!

      • crowbaaaar says:

        you love this song because everyday….sorry every 10 min its played on the radio if the mia song was on the radio everyday youd be backing up mia instaed of rihanna

    11. Mark says:

      I seen both and the only thing in common is the colors. There are tons of videos that look alike, there are tons of movies that looks alike. So “MIAm being a b$$$h” needs to get over it, didn’t her team say that they got the ideal from 80′s videos? Plus it’s island style and Rih is from there, meaning it’s her culture. Everyone can take as long as they put in and Rih did her share of putting in the pot.

    12. MRSZCHRISBREEZY says:

      RIHANNA’S VIDEO IZ BETTA OF COURSE DA ONLY THANG DAT REALLY LOOKS ALIKE IZ DA COLORZ

    13. James says:

      Eh, of course Rihanna’s PR team must have recognized the similarites. Rihanna’s video is better although she, herself, did not come up with the idea, or the song for that matter. M.I.A. pretty much writes all her politically charged lyrics, unlike the robotic Rihanna.

    14. Will says:

      Kinda funny how nobody dissing M.I.A.. Blaadclats too scared?

    15. c33zy says:

      music IS imitation. everyone imitates everyone. get over it.

    16. april says:

      I dont know if its copying. rihanna is from the islands so thats her dancing style too. if rihanna’s peoples are stealing than mia is stealing from the 80s lol.

      • chashmer says:

        you said it!rihanna was not copying mia…rihanna haters r so stupid! if yall gonna say she copied say she copied from the 80s not mia..i saw the same thing in Living Color…and it was director’s idea..so mia copied too..rihanna does write most of her songs but not all.rihanna came in the industry to be a singer not a song writer so james shut ur azz

    17. GaBBo says:

      I think peoples judgements are influenced by the different songs when judging the vids. Maybe try watch it with no music. Rihannah’s vid and MIA’s vid show different personas but they are based on the same style. If basing your video on a style (which is owned by no one) isn’t a crime then its not copying. Both vids hold their own.

    18. ?Stupid says:

      To all the people that say that MIA’s video was “cheap” or “thrown together”. You have to understand that she doesn’t have the million dollar MACHINE that is behind Rihanna. MIA had a fraction of the budget Rihanna did. What she DID have was the BALLS to put her video out YEARS before Rihanna did. You have to give MIA credit for having some courage and not following anyone, and don’t hold her small budget against her.

      • chashmer says:

        the show called living color did the same thing

      • chashmer says:

        i agree .rihanna is more successful than mia lol..thats why shes so jealous

        • cheng says:

          yes, MIA is jealous because Rihanna had more money to throw around for her video clip, MIA is also jealous because Rihanna sold her soul to commercial pop/rnb just to write “songs” for suckers like you. Right.

          • Rihanna what? says:

            I KNOW YOURE JEALOUS! RIHANNA LOOKS 10X BETTER THAN U FOOL. AT LEAST YOU ADMIT IT. ITS ALL FEMALES TYPING BAD THINGS ABOUT RIHANNA AND IF YOURE NOT FEMALE YOURE A GAY GUY.THATS ALL IT IS (JEALOUSY)…

            • SmarterThanYou says:

              Everyone on here sounds ignorant. Congrats, you have proved that arguing over a music video is more important than hmmm, getting an education or possibly helping someone else. Impressive.

    19. ?Stupid says:

      Ohh to that complete idiots that think that the only think similar iz da colrz. Please put the blunt down get your head on right, Rihanna video steals style, graphics, editing etc… you can inhale now razzzclaat.

    20. Kevin says:

      rihanna’s one is more glamorous! I don’t like M.I.A.’s ‘Boyz’ video.. it looks like a very cheep production..

    21. Ashleyyyy says:

      Lmao is it that serious?

    22. rita r says:

      just caught a glimpse of ri’s vid and immediately thought it bit off a MIA’s boyz vid.

      of course ri’s is “better.” she’s got all the cash behind her to make it “better.” but that’s not the point here.

      she straight up BIT off a MIA. wtf? ri fans: you have to recognize that that was wrong.

      this is classic manufactured music vs. artistry, with rihanna being the former and MIA being the latter.

      it’s sad that some folks can’t see that.

    23. Brittany says:

      First of all Rihanna and Mia Put effort into both videos and they added there culture into it it dosn’t matter who copied who music and vids is music and vids it dont matter but at the same time i knoee that nun of them tried to copy it its like when u like sum u want it thats the same thing rihanna did they both put there culters in it and it seems fair to say that MIA S*cks nd Rihanna is better Lmaoo!

    24. bianca says:

      Who cares nobody is original anymore except I guess lady gaga until somebody posts some facts on how she’s not original.

    25. Boney says:

      Has Rhianna EVER done anything original? Neva…eva…eva…ay…ay…

    26. LA-LA LAND says:

      I think people are only hating on Rihanna because she went out with Chris Brown well that relationship had nothing to do with and body in the world but the two.
      And they got in that fight and she took him to court and almost made him lose his record deal……. what ever the case is yall need to stop. she better then most of these fake females out here like Nicki Minaj Nicki lawenski of who ever they hell she want to be oh yeah and im siding with Robyn ”Rihanna” Fenty and Maya Arulpragasam lame and her video was boring

    27. Jayda says:

      Whose M.I.A Was She One Who Sang ‘Paper Planes’ If Soo LOOOL Rihanna Is Far Betta.

    28. chashmer says:

      Mia is just jealous that rihanna did a better job and to all the rihanna haters she is not a gimmick ok.rihanna is a gorgeous girl with style and shes mad because people were into rihanna’s video not hers.dont be mad at rihanna get mad at the director.

    29. lieess says:

      Rihanna sucks
      First she is a rockchick and now she is the cool nice jamaica girl with her new, ‘nice’ musicvideo
      I do like the song but not the video
      MIA the best

      x

    30. Anon. says:

      Get over it. Acting like video concepts don’t get stole all the time.

      Also.. the person MIA RT’d can’t spell for sh!t.

    31. Otto says:

      Rihanna is a gimmick. She’s rated ‘R’ now. She’s the female gimmick of WWE’s Edge… M.I.A. > Rihanna (both look-wise and more importantly as an artist). Also, M.I.A. > GaGa. M.I.A. is just tellin’ the troof, but 85% of America is blind. That’s why you rarely hear or see real art in the mainstream. The mainstream is filled w/ suckers that follow what’s hot and trendy. They can’t think for themselves.

    32. Otto says:

      Rihanna uses ghostwriters, too. It’s a well known fact.

    33. Aperson says:

      Yeah it was stolen, I don’t blame rihanna, its the director who has no creativity. That is sooooo laaaame. I like MIA video more.. more dudes and less …. rihanna………..

    34. Christina says:

      I absolutely love the Rude Boy video but uhhhh Rihanna is def a swagger jocker…. If it were just the video I would blame it on the director but Rihanna is known for this kind of thing.

    35. Steph says:

      Yea she stole it from M.I.A but hers is better except for the fact theres to much of her

    36. Team rihanna says:

      f*ck you mia.you s$$k!

      • SmarterThanYou says:

        …..haha, glad to see we have some really bright minds. Its a pathetic note on society when people spend more time on a computer babbling then out in the world trying to do something productive with their lives. “f*ck you mia. you s$$k!” WOW

    37. Ling says:

      Did like Ri’z clip till I saw the similarities.. come on why
      hate when you can appreciate.. M.I.A. not hating just telling it like it is.. and this the second time Ri biting on M.I.A. she covered Paper Planes on NZ tour dang nasally
      and tryhard!

    38. Smile. =] says:

      To be honest, they’re both entertaining videos. But you must admit, the concept was truly stolen from M.I.A’s video. It’s not about the quality of the video or whose video you think was BETTER, it’s what went on in the video.

      M.I.A’s videos have pretty much always been like that for the most part. Whoever directs them has a very creative mind to match M.I.A’s outwordly creative lyrics.

      At the same time Rihanna’s videos change. One minute they want her to be with her roots, the next they want her to lose the accent and twirl around an umbrella.

      Either way… watch the clips, it’s not about the quality… but the concept in M.I.A’s video is what is viewed in Rihanna’s video. Point Blank… the concept was stolen. Moving on…

    39. Nicole says:

      Personally, I don’t see anything similar about the videos.

    40. Suzie says:

      What is the big deal here?
      People bashing eachother over 2 pop-stars supposedly dissing one another?
      How low can you go?
      I actually like both of these ladies and I hope they will continue their great work.
      Peace

    41. team rihanna says:

      mia we dont care if you think rihanna copied your video because at the end of the day rihanna is kicking your a## and why do people call rihanna out for copying when there are others that do it??

      because shes the best!
      and they know it!

    42. It's Just Me! says:

      M.I.A needs to shut her stupid mouth, because shes just hating that Rihanna’s video is waaaay better.

      M.I.A your track is s$$t, you’re s$$t and the video….yeah you guessed it s$$t!

    43. TJ says:

      M.I.A GET OVER YOURSELF!!!

      We all live in the same world so are bound to attract similar influences. The video making process is complex, you have to brainstorm to the director the feeling you want to provoke, the style, sometimes you have to refer to what’s out there as an example.

      How many Hip Hop Videos look alike? Nuff!!! If every video that was similar to another was binned, there would be no music videos at all!!! God help rock videos with the same Live band concert scenes!!!

      The Rude Boy Video was perfect for the song, and i couldn’t see how it could have been better executed.

      This is a STYLE. M.I.A, you are not as original as you think!

      If M.I.A. can say Rihanna is ripping off her vid, then she in turn must be accused of ripping off Neneh Cherry’s 1980′s vid Buffalo stance!!! Not the same colours but exactly the same style. In fact the idea and concept seem almost identical!!!

      Seems like M.I.A. has an over inflated opinion of her own self-importance. Big up to Rihanna who has had more verbal beat downs than physical ones.

      Haters stop Hating… Live and let live. Stop looking for the bad in others to make yourself feel better. Focus on your selves and how to improve your own situation.

    44. sue says:

      I want to know the defintion of rudeboy.

    45. SWAGGA JOCKIN says:

      Rihanna’s video does somewhat resemble m.i.a’s vidoe but i like both of them.

      everybody copies everybody so what’s the big deal?
      I dont think M.I.A is jealous of Rihanna, she isnt that pretty! Almost all female artists have to be half naked in their videos to get attention(beyonce,nicki minaj,rihanna,ciara,etc.!) so if u ask me everyone needs to get over it! and these female artist need 2 put some clothes on to show young women that they dont have to b half naked to get attention! peace!!

      • SmarterThanYou says:

        Well said.

      • cherri says:

        please rihanna isnt that pretty???? rihanna is beautiful unlike mia..mia ugly like hell….rihanna copies please..rihanna is being swagger jacked by so many people..not just in the industry but everywhere….people wanted to change their image when rihanna did it…like keyshia cole,ciara,keri hilson,beyonce, and even niki minaj has swagger jacked rihanna’s singing technique in her new song…all these hoes copied her and yall wanna take about rihanna being a swagger jacker….if i see one more person with a bald head! these hoes look up to my girl riri..stop hating

    46. darq says:

      MIA = more carribian/dancehall so for most americans its weird/underground.

      Rihanna = mainstream american, so obviously her vid would seem better to americans

      BUT, it seems MIA’s vid was supposed to look ‘cheesy’ its done on purpose…. or she woulda catered more to the american audience like in ‘paper planes’.

    47. Ling says:

      I don’t understand why peepz make remarks about their looks saying ones prettier than the other. They both striking lady’s you Rihanna fans wanna hate on M.I.A. yall actually appreciate her style come on and what! And you say peepz controlling Ri her well then she just another Klingon 5 finger say what….thats wassup :P bleh

      • cherri says:

        lol who the hell would hate on mia..the one hit wonder..when she starts selling more than rihanna yall can talk but the b$$$h shouldnt have s$$t to say…nobody is hating on her style..shes just ugly…mia is the one hating on rihanna because rihanna did a better job than her..mia sucks

    48. John says:

      MIA’s styling w/ Janelle Monae hair. I like you Rihanna, but come on! You’ve got all that big-budget, major-label push behind you, and you’re copying a (awesome, nonetheless) video that looks like it was produced for $1000?

      MIA’s right on this one. Plus, “Boyz” is a better song anyway.

    49. Str8UP says:

      SOrry…..M.I.A….the videos are different..
      and I love Rihanna’s beat and vid..

      Next.

    50. Mario says:

      first of all who the f*ck is mia or m.i.a(what the hell) rihannas outfit background and move are much better than that sh*t mia calls a song the graphics may be similar but that means riri admires mias work and decided to use it as a foundation u dont see that she did a much better job on the video and it sounded better 2

    51. Myhonestopinion says:

      Really I think, most of these comments are a bunch of crap. You really have to give them BOTH a chance, I love M.I.A.’s music and some of Rihanna’s. But most of Rihanna’s songs are sad. And almost all of M.I.A.’s music is Happy-party-go-dance. I have my own negative opinions on them both and they are both very sucessful. And yeah Rihanna’s vid. does look quite similar to M.I.A.’s sh*t but hey? Is that stopping me from watching it? (pause).

    52. nicole says:

      Rihanna’s wack, end of story

    53. sds in Oz says:

      Sure, there are certain elements that are similar. Should MIA be up in beef about it? I don’t think so: Even if Matsoukas directly borrowed some of the elements, such as the animation, the new video has a different approach and context that I think it transforms into a totally different personality as a separate song. I hardly would say it is a ‘rip-off.’ Plus, I’d be interested to know how much borrowing MIA has done for her music. Unless she’s a total originalist I don’t think she can make a heavy stab at Rihanna’s video.

    54. mya says:

      rihanna copies everybody.her and beyonce just want to be so popular and known.no matter both of them do their videos are their music’s are not the best.nobodies perfect.but i would give the award to mia for a sexy video and rihanna for a hot song.

    55. Nadine says:

      Rihanna is wack as hell, and she does copy everybody. She doesn’t have a lick of talent really.

    56. Nadine says:

      Rihanna is wack, and she does copy everybody. She doesn’t have a lick of talent really.

    57. Edina says:

      Sure wish M.I.A could spell.

    58. Jamarion Williams says:

      Behold, thou art fair, my love; behold, thou art fair; thou hast doves’ eyes within thy locks: thy hair is as a flock of goats, that appear from mount Gilead. Thy teeth are like a flock of sheep that are even shorn, which came up from the washing; whereof every one bear twins, and none is barren among them. Thy lips are like a thread of scarlet, and thy speech is comely: thy temples are like a piece of a pomegranate within thy locks. Thy neck is like the tower of David builded for an armoury, whereon there hang a thousand bucklers, all shields of mighty men. Thy two breasts are like two young roes that are twins, which feed among the lilies. Until the day break, and the shadows flee away, I will get me to the mountain of myrrh, and to the hill of frankincense. Thou art all fair, my love; there is no spot in thee.
      Come with me from Lebanon, my spouse, with me from Lebanon: look from the top of Amana, from the top of Shenir and Hermon, from the lions’ dens, from the mountains of the leopards. Thou hast ravished my heart, my sister, my spouse; thou hast ravished my heart with one of thine eyes, with one chain of thy neck. How fair is thy love, my sister, my spouse! how much better is thy love than wine! and the smell of thine ointments than all spices! Thy lips, O my spouse, drop as the honeycomb: honey and milk are under thy tongue; and the smell of thy garments is like the smell of Lebanon. A garden inclosed is my sister, my spouse; a spring shut up, a fountain sealed. Thy plants are an orchard of pomegranates, with pleasant fruits; camphire, with spikenard, Spikenard and saffron; calamus and cinnamon, with all trees of frankincense; myrrh and aloes, with all the chief spices:
      A fountain of gardens, a well of living waters, and streams from Lebanon.
      Awake, O Rihanna; and come, thou south; blow upon my garden, that the spices thereof may flow out. Let my beloved come into her garden, and eat her pleasant fruits. I Truly Love You Lil RiRi